Ah, Monday again. Whilst sadly, I do not have tales of another Octo-date (thank you, Lembo) with which to regale you, it was an interesting weekend, at least from an observer’s point of view. I spent a lot of time talking to a lot of people about relationships (apparently, the stars and moon and planets aligned perfectly this weekend for everyone’s lives to just go ka-blooey) which, at least for the purpose of this li’l ol’ blog, is always a good thing.
Today, for your consideration, we have the story of my friend Julie, who this weekend succeeded in consummating a flirtatious tryst with a long-time friend and crush. Great success, right? Well, not quite, as the guy in question (who has never shied away from being flirty, romantic, or teasing in this relationship) is currently sort-of-but-not-quite seeing another girl who lives out of state. They’re not official, so technically he didn’t do anything wrong – except for ensnare Julie in a tangled web of sex, deceit and confused.
“What should I do? I don’t know what he wants!” Julie cried of a glass of wine at my house last night. (Oh, gee, where have I heard this before?)
“Here’s the thing,” I said, trying, despite all evidence to the contrary, to be the voice of reason, “he can’t really be that into that girl if he’s fucking you.“
I’ve actually been saying this, or some variation thereof, for years. I feel like this is one of those universal relationship truths – if you are having sex with someone besides your significant other, then you are just not that into your significant other, regardless of what you tell yourself.
Now, obviously, I know we’re all only human, and we all have animalistic instincts and desires that can be very powerful. Likewise, being in a monogamous relationship is not the same as being dead. People are going to notice members of the opposite sex, especially those they find attractive. They may look at them, think about them, fantasize about them – but there is a big difference between all of that, and getting naked with somebody. And when clothes come off, then you know there’s a problem.
People will explain their infidelities in a bevy of ways – “We had a fight and I wanted to get back at you.” “I was drunk.” “I was curious.” “I was horny.” Or my favorite, “It was an accident.” (Really, honey? You just tripped and landed on somebody’s dick?) But the one thing these explanations all have in common is that they are merely excuses used to cover up the real, universal reason that people cheat – because they are unhappy and unsatisfied in their relationships.
That’s a hard thing to admit, and perhaps that is why people cheat in the first place – it’s hard to approach your partner and tell them that your relationship, your life with them, is no longer fulfilling. It’s much easier (and seemingly harmless) to just hop off for a night, find some suitable stranger, and seek fulfillment with them. And I’m not even talking about sexual fulfillment. Generally, in my experience, sex is the last thing cheating is about. It’s involved, certainly, but I’ve known more people who have cheated for every reason besides sex – myself included.
I have been unfaithful in relationships twice. I’m not proud of it, but I’ll admit it. Both times it was because I was unhappy in my relationship; my emotional and mental needs weren’t being met; oddly enough, the physical aspect of those relationships were the best part. But because I felt something lacking, I went searching for it elsewhere. It’s dishonest and hurtful and immature, but it was a lot easier than taking the honest way out and actually telling my significant other that I was unhappy (which I eventually did, in both situations, when I broke up with them.) I’m not trying to justify my actions, and it is something I will always be ashamed of, but I’m just saying, I understand why it happens.
Cheating doesn’t need to necessarily involve sex, either. There is that gray area that my friend Ang and I call “emotional affairs.” This is basically when someone who is in a relationship winds up being more emotionally involved with someone outside the relationship – sharing intimate feelings and thoughts with a third party, rather than a significant other, rendering the actual exclusive relationship superficial and monotonous. There are even those who argue that an emotional affair is more damaging than a sexual affair, but that kind of depends on a person’s personal views of sex and intimacy.
So why do people stay with a partner they are unfaithful too, either sporadically or consistently? I can only speculate. Comfort, I think, is a big thing. If you’ve found someone you’re comfortable with, who loves you and gives you that security, it’s very hard to give it up, regardless of how unfulfilled you are. Guilt, maybe – staying with a person with whom you are unhappy is penance for the sin of infidelity. And genuine feelings, too, can keep couples together. Even if a person is unfaithful, they can still care about their partner, and not want to hurt him or her by ending it. There’s practical reasons, too – kids, money, shared property. There’s a lot of reasons, and some of them are even understandable, or decent. But at the end of the day, if someone is really happy in his or her relationship, they don’t even want to look at another member of the opposite sex, let alone sleep with them or open up to them. And really, isn’t that the kind of relationship we all want?