First of all, I want to take a moment to acknowledge my current love/hate relationship with Mother Nature (if we get this impending Snowstorm of Doom and I have off work tomorrow and can therefore spend this evening getting shitfaced and playing Rock Band, I love you. If it does not snow, and my sparkling coming-out as a playwright was postponed for nothing, and I have to come into work with a hangover, I hate you.)
Now that that’s out of our way, let’s turn our attention to this article that I found on Yahoo! yesterday – “7 Mistakes Single Women Make.” Obviously, with a title like that, I was bound to be intrigued. I mean, is this not what I have been asking myself for at least the last year and a half? What am I doing wrong? Why can’t I make it work? Why? Why? Why?
Well, according to Lori Gottlieb, author of Marry Him: The Case for Settling for Mr. Good Enough, it’s because I (and most single women) are neurotic, picky, conceited, judgmental maximizers who feel they are entitled to a perfect man who suits all of their needs and wants.
Ok, maybe she doesn’t say that exactly, but read between the lines, and the message is clear: Single ladies, you need to chill the fuck out, adjust your standards, and settle for someone who maybe isn’t perfect, but is pretty close.
Which is all fine and good, except that for our entire lives, women in my generation have been told not to settle – don’t settle for a lesser education, lesser pay, lesser opportunities, and certainly not a lesser man. Even someone like me, who was in no way raised with a sense of entitlement (when I got my driver’s license and broached the subject of a car with my parents, I was told, “You want your own car, get a job and pay for it.”), was always told that there was no reason I should compromise my standards and expectations for a man. If that’s what I was going to have to do to get a boyfriend, I was better off alone. And I know I’m not the only young woman who’s been told this. From the media to our mothers, my fellow female Millenials have heard the refrain again and again: “You are great, and you deserve nothing but the best.” And that’s an excellent message, don’t get me wrong. It’s made my generation ambitious, empowered, confident…and neurotic, picky and judgmental.
I can recall many an impassioned, desperate conversation with another female that includes some variation of the line, “Who thinks I would actually date this guy?” And while there are plenty of guys out there who truly are undateable to anyone with standards, there’s a much larger population of men out there who fall into the sort of black hole of “good enough…but not good enough.” You know, a guy who is maybe not as attractive as you would like, or not as smart, or has some annoying habit, but who otherwise would be good enough - were we not convinced that we not only can but should do better. So we keep looking, keep hunting for that needle in the haystack, bemoaning the whole time that there is not one single man worth dating left on Earth.
But does that make Gottlieb right? Should women settle? If so, when? I was having this discussion with my friend Carly the other day, about how we might feel differently about the whole concept of “settling” for a guy in, say, 10 years, or 15 years. There’s a certain degree of invincibility one feels at 25, when life and opportunities are stretching before you, and you can say, “I have plenty of time to find my ‘Mr. Right.’” But what about when you’re 40, and your biological clock is ticking, your friends are married, and your family is starting to age? Then maybe settling doesn’t look like such a bad thing.
How will the women of our generation handle that? Will we be able to handle it, or will we be so resistant to the concept of “settling” that we just end up bitter spinsters, bemused by the fact that we could never find a man worthy of us.
Maybe that’s Gottlieb’s whole M.O. – to start preparing the females of our generation for the inevitable moment when we have to settle. I’d venture a guess, though, that it will take more than one book to convince me and my fellow females that we are fabulous and great, and deserve anything less than the best.
And on a final note, I take issue with Gottlieb’s assertion that guy’s are not as judgmental as women. Bull. Pucky. Guys will nix a girl for just as many reasons as a girl will nix a guy; it may just seem like they can find three things wrong with a girl because they can’t articulate as well as women.